The Torrance Noise Abatement Department falsely claims it has authority to enforce its rules on "prohibited operations" at Torrance Airport.
The attached letters, although addressing only one of the "prohibited operations" (early left turns--TMC 51.2.3E), clearly address the City's lack of authority to regulate aircraft in flight such as "low approaches" (TMC 51.5.4, 51.5.6 & 51.5.7) and other "prohibited operations." The regulation of aircraft flight operations rests solely with the FAA. Title 49 of the United States Code, section 40103(a)(1), states: "The US Government has exclusive sovereignty of airspace of the United States."
The FAA created the National Airspace System (NAS) to protect persons and property on the ground, and to establish a safe and efficient airspace environment for civil, commercial, and military aviation. The NAS is made up of a network of air navigation facilities, ATC facilities, airports, technology, and appropriate rules and regulations that are needed to operate the system. It includes airports, air traffic control and ground services that manage aircraft starting right from taxiing on the airport surface, through takeoff, terminal area operations, en route travel, and final landing.
This means that any attempt by the City to regulate the airspace above the city or on the airport has been preempted.
On 8/11/2026. I submitted a California Public Records Act (CPRA) request for "All records in which the FAA ceded to the City of Torrance any portion of their exclusive authority, given to them by Congress, to regulate the National Airspace System and thus make Torrance Municipal Code sections 51.2.3e, and 51.5.5 through 51.5.7 valid, enforceable and not preempted by Federal Law."
On 8/17/2026. I received a reply: "the City of Torrance General Services (Airport) Department has reviewed its files and has determined that there are no documents responsive to your request," On that date, I extended the CPRA request to include "any such documents anywhere in the City."
To date, no such documents have been produced by the City of Torrance, which continues to request additional time to process my request. The staff report recommending the adoption of Ordinance 3930, which established the "prohibited operations," contained no reference to an FAA release of any portion of their exclusive authority over the NAS.
My conclusion, subject to production of the requested documents, is that the "prohibited operations" are invalid, unenforceable and preempted by Federal Law.
ATTACHMENTS:
8/9/2022 Letter from Sara L Mikolop, FAA Acting Assistant Chief Counsel for
Regulations
2/18/2020 Letter from Lorelei A Peter, FAA Assistant Chief Counsel, Regulations Division